How PTs Can Safely Train Clients With Injury: PARQ, Consent, Risk Checks, and Exercise Modifications
Updated: 3 days ago
A few days ago, two of my students were in with me to complete some Level 2 Fitness Coach practical work. However, one was injured - having has a recent knee operation. Rather than cancel the session, we made adaptions. Here's the process:
Training someone with an illness or injury is not just a matter of “going lighter” or swapping one exercise for another. A safe session starts before the warm-up. A PT needs to understand the client’s health status, know when to refer, explain the risks, gain consent, and then choose exercises that match the person in front of them.
For a personal trainer, this process protects the client and sets clear professional boundaries. It also improves the quality of the programme. A client with knee pain, for example, might still be able to train well with seated exercises, reduced range of motion, or isometric work. The key is knowing what is appropriate, what needs caution, and what sits outside the PT’s scope. And documenting EVERYTHING!
This article is for general information only. It is not medical advice. Clients with injury, illness, unexplained symptoms, or changing health status should be assessed or cleared by an appropriate healthcare professional before taking part in exercise.

The PT’s first job is to screen before prescribing
A PT should never begin by guessing what a client can tolerate. Screening gives a structured picture of the client’s health, current limitations, and possible risk factors.
The process usually starts with a health questionnaire, often known as a PARQ or PAR-Q. This stands for Physical Activity Readiness Questionnaire. It asks about issues that may affect exercise safety, such as:
Chest pain or discomfort during activity
Dizziness, fainting, or unexplained breathlessness
Heart, blood pressure, or circulation problems
Bone, joint, or muscle problems
Recent surgery or hospital treatment
Medication that may affect exercise response
Pregnancy or recent childbirth
Existing medical conditions, such as diabetes, asthma, arthritis, or neurological conditions
A PARQ is not a diagnosis. It is a screening tool. Its job is to identify whether the client can start low-risk exercise, needs modifications, or should seek medical clearance before training.
If a client answers “yes” to a health concern, the PT should ask appropriate follow-up questions within their scope. For example, if the client reports knee pain, useful questions may include:
When did the pain start?
Was there a clear injury or accident?
What movements make it worse?
What movements feel manageable?
Has it been assessed by a doctor, physiotherapist, or other clinician?
Are there any restrictions or advice from a healthcare professional?
Is there swelling, locking, giving way, numbness, or sharp pain?
Some answers should trigger referral rather than training. Red flags include sudden severe pain, chest pain, fainting, unexplained shortness of breath, acute swelling after injury, loss of sensation, signs of infection, or symptoms that are getting worse without explanation.
A good PT does not try to “work around” serious warning signs. They pause, document the concern, and recommend medical advice.
Informed consent means the client understands the plan
Once screening is complete, the PT should explain the proposed exercise plan and gain informed consent. This is more than asking, “Are you happy to train?”
Informed consent means the client understands:
What the session or programme involves
Why certain exercises have been chosen
What the expected benefits are
What the possible risks or discomforts may be
What alternatives are available
That they can stop or ask to change an exercise at any time
What information may need to be shared, if referral or collaboration is required
Consent should be clear, voluntary, and ongoing. A client may consent to a programme at the start, then withdraw consent during a session if pain increases or they feel unwell. The PT must respect that.
For example, a client with a knee injury may agree to avoid deep knee flexion and start with seated leg extensions through a small, pain-free range. If that still causes discomfort, the PT should not pressure them to “push through”. The programme should be adjusted.
Good consent also includes setting realistic expectations. A PT should not promise to “fix” an injury unless they are also qualified to diagnose and treat that condition. A safer message is:
“We can adapt your training around your symptoms and follow any guidance from your clinician. If symptoms worsen or do not behave as expected, we will pause and refer.”
That kind of clarity builds trust. It also keeps the PT inside their professional role.
Risk stratification helps decide the safest route
After screening and consent, the PT needs to decide the client’s broad level of exercise risk. This is called risk stratification. It helps answer a simple question: can this person train normally, train with modifications, or do they need medical input first?
Risk stratification looks at the whole person, not just the injury. A knee injury in an otherwise healthy adult may be lower risk than knee pain in someone with uncontrolled diabetes, recent cardiac symptoms, or dizziness during activity.
A practical risk guide may look like this:
Risk level | Typical presentation | PT action |
Lower risk | Minor, stable issue. No red flags. Client can complete daily tasks and has no concerning medical symptoms. | Begin with conservative exercise, monitor response, and progress slowly. |
Moderate risk | Known medical condition, persistent injury, medication considerations, or unclear exercise tolerance. | Modify the session, keep intensity controlled, and request guidance or clearance where needed. |
Higher risk | Chest pain, fainting, unexplained breathlessness, acute injury signs, neurological symptoms, severe swelling, or worsening symptoms. | Do not train the affected issue. Refer to a suitable healthcare professional. |
Risk stratification is not a one-time event. It can change. A client may arrive one week feeling fine and the next week report swelling, sleep disruption from pain, or new medication. The PT should reassess and adjust the plan.
This is why every session should include a brief check-in. Useful questions include:
How have you felt since the last session?
Did any exercise cause pain during or after training?
Has anything changed with your health, medication, or injury?
What is your energy level today?
Are there any movements you are worried about?
The answers guide the session. They also show that safety is part of the coaching process, not paperwork filed away at the start.
A risk assessment turns screening into practical decisions
Risk stratification gives the broad category. A risk assessment looks at the specific session, environment, and exercise choices.
For a PT, this means assessing what could go wrong and reducing the chance of harm. The same client may tolerate one exercise well and struggle with another. The assessment should cover the client, the movement, the load, and the setting.
Key areas include:
The client’s current symptoms
Pain, fatigue, swelling, stiffness, balance, confidence, and recent flare-ups all matter.
The exercise selection
The PT should choose movements that match the client’s current ability. A painful deep squat may become a box squat, sit-to-stand, wall squat, or seated leg exercise.
The range of motion
Full range is not always the right starting point. Reduced range of motion can keep the movement tolerable while still allowing strength and control to improve.
The load and speed
Slower tempo, lighter resistance, and fewer repetitions may reduce irritation. Heavy, fast, or high-impact work may need to wait.
The training environment
Flooring, equipment set-up, trip hazards, space, and supervision all affect safety.
The response during and after exercise
The PT should monitor pain, effort, breathing, technique, and any unusual symptoms. A useful rule is to avoid movements that cause sharp pain, worsening symptoms, or altered movement patterns that the client cannot control.
For many clients, a small amount of manageable discomfort may be expected, especially with chronic conditions. But the PT should use conservative judgement and follow any healthcare guidance. Pain that escalates during the session, lasts much longer than usual, or changes the client’s ability to move should prompt a review.

Exercise modifications should solve a specific problem
Exercise modification works best when the PT knows what they are trying to change. The goal might be to reduce joint load, avoid painful angles, improve balance, limit fatigue, or keep the client active while an injury settles.
For a knee injury, common modifications include seated exercises, supported standing work, reduced range of motion, lower impact choices, and isometric holds.
Training goal | Standard exercise | Possible modification |
Lower body strength | Squat | Box squat, wall squat, sit-to-stand, or reduced-range squat |
Quad strength | Leg press or lunge | Seated knee extension within a comfortable range |
Hip strength | Walking lunges | Supported step-back pattern, glute bridge, or side-lying hip abduction |
Conditioning | Running or jumping | Cycling, rowing if tolerated, swimming, or seated circuits |
Balance and control | Single-leg squat | Supported single-leg stand or split stance hold |
Whole-body training | Standing circuit | Seated upper-body circuit with light resistance |
A client with knee pain might complete a session like this:
Seated chest press with resistance bands
Seated row
Seated overhead press, if shoulder mobility allows
Glute bridge, if comfortable
Seated knee extension through a short range
Supported sit-to-stand from a high box
Low-resistance cycling, if it does not increase symptoms
This keeps the client moving without forcing the painful area through a high-load or deep-range pattern. It also maintains confidence, which matters. Many clients fear losing fitness when injured. A safe modified plan helps them stay consistent.
Reduced range of motion can be especially useful. If a full squat causes pain below a certain depth, the PT may use a higher box or limit the movement to the pain-free portion. Over time, range can be increased if symptoms allow and the client has suitable clearance.
The same idea can apply to upper-body injuries. A client with shoulder pain may use a neutral grip, reduce overhead work, limit pressing range, or choose pulling exercises that feel stable and controlled.
The aim is not to avoid all challenge. The aim is to apply the right challenge.
Isometric exercise can help when movement is painful
Isometric exercises involve producing force without visible joint movement. The client holds a position or pushes against an immovable object. This can be helpful when joint mobility is limited, painful, or temporarily not appropriate.
For example, a client with knee pain may struggle with repeated bending and straightening. Instead, the PT might use:
Wall sit at a shallow knee angle
Seated quad set, pressing the back of the knee gently towards a towel
Isometric leg extension hold against a fixed resistance
Glute bridge hold
Split stance hold with support, if tolerated
Isometrics can be useful because they allow the client to work muscles around the joint while controlling the joint angle. The PT can choose a position that feels stable and avoids the painful range.
For a knee injury, a shallow wall sit may be more tolerable than repeated squats. For a shoulder issue, an isometric external rotation hold against a wall or band may be more suitable than repeated pressing. For a painful wrist, an isometric grip or forearm hold may be used before loading through the hand.
The PT should still monitor symptoms carefully. Isometric does not automatically mean safe for everyone. The hold should be controlled, breathing should remain steady, and the client should not brace so hard that they create pain elsewhere. People with certain cardiovascular concerns may need extra caution with sustained holds, especially if they hold their breath or strain.
A sensible starting point is often a low to moderate effort hold in a comfortable position. The PT can adjust:
Hold duration
Effort level
Joint angle
Number of sets
Rest time
Support or equipment used
Progression may involve longer holds, more effort, different angles, or returning to slow dynamic movement when tolerated. Remember, the goal during injury is to 'Do No Harm' and aim t oprevent further damage or muscle loss initially, before slow progression back to normal fitness.
Documentation protects the client and the PT
Safe practice needs good records. Documentation does not have to be complicated, but it should be clear.
A PT should record:
PARQ answers and any follow-up notes
Medical clearance or professional guidance, if provided
The consent discussion
Risk stratification decision
Session risk assessment
Exercise modifications
Pain or symptom responses
Referrals or advice to seek medical input
Programme changes over time
If a client reports knee pain during a session, the notes should show what happened. For example, the PT might record that lunges caused discomfort, the exercise was stopped, a supported reduced-range sit-to-stand was used instead, and the client was advised to monitor symptoms and seek clinical advice if pain persisted.
This level of detail supports continuity. It also shows that decisions were made with care, not guesswork.
Progression should be gradual and evidence-led
Once a client trains without symptom increase, the PT can consider progression. Progression should be based on response, not enthusiasm alone.
Useful signs include:
The client completes exercises with steady technique
Symptoms stay stable during and after sessions
Daily activities are not made worse
Range of motion improves or remains comfortable
Confidence increases
The client can describe what feels safe and what does not
Progression might involve a slightly larger range of motion, a small increase in resistance, more repetitions, or a more demanding variation. Only one or two variables should change at a time. If the PT increases load, range, speed, and volume all at once, it becomes hard to know what caused a flare-up.
For the knee injury example, a progression might move from seated knee extension to supported sit-to-stand, then to a higher box squat, then to a lower box squat, then to a split squat pattern if appropriate.
There should also be a plan to regress. If symptoms increase, the PT can return to the last well-tolerated variation. This is not failure. It is good coaching.
The safest PTs know their limits
A PT can play a valuable role in helping someone stay active with an illness or injury. They can screen, adapt, monitor, educate, and encourage. They can build sessions that respect pain, mobility limits, fatigue, and medical guidance.
They should not diagnose injuries, override clinical advice, treat medical conditions outside their qualification, or pressure clients through warning symptoms.
The safe process is simple in principle:
Screen with a PARQ and follow-up questions.
Refer or request clearance when needed.
Gain informed consent.
Use risk stratification to judge the level of caution required.
Complete a practical risk assessment for the session.
Modify exercises to match the client’s current ability.
Monitor symptoms and document decisions.
Progress gradually when the client is ready.
Good training with an injury is still training. It is planned, measured, and purposeful. The difference is that every exercise has to earn its place. When a PT follows a clear safety process, clients can often keep moving, maintain strength, and build confidence while reducing unnecessary risk.
Please do use this guidance - and if you need any paperwork examples (risk stratifications etc) then please email me! paul@trainermaker.com
Paul




Comments